But don't worry, there's always life after "The Bachelorette". Many have also protested showrunner Mike Fleiss's decision to not cast a person of color, noting that there has yet to be a black Bachelor.
"I don't want to be over-confident but I feel like we're in a good place", she said in the preview clip.
The Bachelor season 23 will air in 2019.
The former National Football League player made headlines after Becca Kufrin's season of The Bachelorette for revealing that he's a virgin and that he dated former Bachelor contestant Tia Booth - who appeared on season 22 of The Bachelor as a contestant for Arie Luyendyk Jr. - before joining the reality show.
"Producers knew a lot of fans were into Jason Tartick and Blake Horstmann, but Colton's whole narrative was just too good to pass up", the source reveals.
The 26-year-old gained attention for opening up about his virginity on Kufrin's season, where he placed fourth.
Lallana, Shaw, Tarkowski and Gomez named in England squad
That's opened up places for Joe Gomez in central defender and Southampton's Alex McCarthy in the goalkeeping division. It was great that we were able to have mature conversations about that. "The door's certainly not closed".
But Underwood and Booth ultimately called it quits on Paradise's September 3 episode, after the pro football player confessed he couldn't see a long-term relationship panning out between them.
"I'm very excited", Underwood told Strahan. She added a few hashtags including #peaceoutparadise and #hotdogsforever, and it sounds as if this Bachelor in Paradise contestant is relieved that everybody finally knows where things stand for her in regards to Colton.
Football player Colton Underwood and Olympic gymnast Aly Raisman attend the Sports Illustrated Sportsperson of the Year Ceremony 2016 at Barclays Center of Brooklyn on December 12, 2016 in New York City.
Tia also confirmed via Twitter that she would not be a contestant on Colton's season of The Bachelor.
When he came clean to Tia about his feelings, they had a very emotional break up, with both deciding to leave Paradise in the aftermath.